How to Choose an Expat Tax Professional: Your Complete Selection Guide
Choosing the right expat tax professional can save you thousands of dollars—but picking the wrong one could cost you even more. With taxes for Americans abroad being significantly more complex than domestic filings, selecting the best expat tax professional requires careful evaluation.
This guide provides objective criteria for evaluating expat tax services, red flags to avoid, and key questions to ask before making your decision.
DIY Software vs. Professional Services: Making the Right Choice
Your first decision: handle it yourself or hire an expert?
Choose DIY Software If You:
- Have only foreign employment income under $130,000
- Qualify clearly for the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion
- Have no foreign accounts over $10,000
- Are comfortable navigating complex forms independently
- Want the lowest upfront cost
Choose Professional Services If You:
- Own property or businesses abroad
- Have multiple income sources or countries involved
- Missed prior-year filings or FBAR requirements
- Need strategic tax planning and optimization
- Want expert IRS representation if issues arise
Reality check: Software might save money initially, but professional mistakes often cost far more than expert fees.
Understanding Professional Credentials
| Credential | Training Required | Can Represent You to IRS | Best For |
| CPA | 4-year degree + extensive testing | Yes | Complex planning, business returns |
| Enrolled Agent | IRS certification exam | Yes | Most expat tax situations |
| Tax Preparer | Varies (may be minimal) | Limited | Basic returns only |
| Tax Attorney | Law degree + bar exam | Yes | Legal issues, audits |
Critical factor: Only CPAs, EAs, and attorneys can represent you before the IRS if complications arise.
Key Questions to Ask Before Choosing
About Their Expat Experience
- What percentage of your clients are American expats?
- How many expat returns do you prepare annually?
- Are you familiar with tax rules in my country of residence?
- Can you handle FBAR, FEIE, and Streamlined Filing?
About Service and Pricing
- What’s included in your quoted price?
- How do you handle questions during the year?
- What’s your typical response time for urgent issues?
- Do you offer year-round support or just tax season help?
About Their Process
- How do you securely handle international document transfers?
- Will I work with the same person each year?
- How do you stay current with changing expat tax laws?
- What happens if the IRS contacts me?
Solo Practitioner vs. Established Firm
Solo Practitioners Offer:
- Direct access to the person preparing your return
- Potentially more personalized service
- Often lower overhead costs
- Flexible, relationship-based approach
Established Firms Provide:
- Backup coverage when your preparer is unavailable
- Standardized processes and quality controls
- Advanced technology platforms
- Multiple specialists for complex situations
- Year-round customer support across time zones
For expats specifically: Firms often work better due to global time zone coverage, backup support during tax season, and resources to handle international complexities.
Pricing Models: Flat-Fee vs. Hourly
| Billing Type | Pros | Cons |
| Flat Fee | Predictable, transparent costs | May seem higher upfront |
| Hourly | Flexible for simple needs | Can escalate quickly with complexity |
Recommendation: Choose flat-fee pricing to avoid surprise bills, especially for complex expat situations.
Red Flags When Evaluating Providers
Avoid Services That:
- Promise unrealistic refunds or “guaranteed” savings
- Can’t explain their experience with expat-specific forms
- Offer vague pricing or seem evasive about costs
- Lack proper credentials or licensing verification
- Take weeks to respond to basic questions
- Seems unfamiliar with the US expat tax system
Warning Signs:
- High-pressure sales tactics or artificial urgency
- Reluctance to provide client references
- No secure document transfer system
- Claims that “all expats owe zero taxes”
- Outdated technology or communication methods
Evaluation Framework: Rating Potential Providers
Must-Have Criteria (Non-Negotiable):
- Expat specialization – The Majority of clients should be American expats
- Proper credentials – Licensed CPAs or EAs handling your return
- Transparent pricing – Clear, upfront fee structure
- Security standards – Encrypted document transfer and storage
- IRS representation – Ability to handle correspondence and audits
Preferred Criteria (Strong Advantages):
- Global accessibility – Support across multiple time zones
- Technology platform – Modern, user-friendly systems
- Track record – Proven results with client testimonials
- Year-round support – Not just tax season availability
- Specialization depth – Experience with your specific situation
Making Your Final Decision
Research Phase:
- Shortlist 3-5 services specializing in expat taxation
- Verify the credentials of preparers who’ll handle your return
- Read recent reviews from expats in similar situations
- Confirm experience with your country and tax situation
Comparison Phase:
- Request detailed quotes for your exact situation
- Schedule consultations to assess knowledge and communication
- Evaluate their process from document collection to filing
- Test their responsiveness and professionalism
Decision Factors to Weight:
- Expat specialization (most important)
- Professional credentials and licensing
- Transparent, predictable pricing
- Responsive communication across time zones
- Technology and security standards
- Track record and client satisfaction
Why Many Expats Choose Greenback
Based on the evaluation criteria above, here’s how Greenback measures up:
- 100% expat focus – Every client is an American abroad
- Licensed professionals only – CPAs and EAs prepare all returns
- Transparent flat-fee pricing – No hidden costs or surprises
- Global team – Support across 14 time zones with many expat accountants
- Proven track record – 23,000+ expats helped, 4.9-star TrustPilot average
- Advanced technology – Secure, expat-optimized platform
- Year-round support – Not limited to tax season
Your Next Steps
Ready to make your decision?
- Use our pricing calculator to get instant quotes for your situation
- Schedule a free consultation to discuss your needs with an expat tax specialist
- Read client reviews to see what other expats say about their experience
Whether you need straightforward expat tax preparation or complex international tax planning, choosing the right professional makes all the difference. Use this guide to evaluate your options and find the expat tax service that best fits your unique situation abroad.
Don’t leave your expat taxes to chance. Make an informed decision and get the expertise you deserve.
Get the Free Download That Makes Filing Taxes Simple
